Key West Hotels: Where to Stay in Key West by Neighborhood
Key West is my go-to. After 20+ trips, I’ve stayed in nearly every part of the island—from buzzy bars at sunset to quiet corners with mid-century flair. And while the island’s charm is everywhere, where you stay matters. The difference between a dreamy escape and a regrettable splurge? One wrong hotel.
In Key West Florida, you'll find a wide range of accommodations, from luxury resorts to budget hotels and unique lodging options, making it easy to find the perfect place to stay in the Florida Keys.
This guide breaks down the best places to stay in Key West by neighborhood and vibe—no fluff, no filler. Whether you want beachfront views, boutique style, or a low-key spot with shuttle service, these hotels actually live up to the moment.
💡 Planning a full trip? Check out my Key West Travel Guide for what to do, eat, and explore.
Introduction to Key West
Key West, the crown jewel of the Florida Keys, is a tropical paradise that draws visitors from around the world. Located at the southernmost tip of Florida, this vibrant island is famous for its laid-back vibe, colorful history, and endless sunshine. Stroll through Key West’s historic Old Town and you’ll find charming streets lined with pastel-hued homes, lively restaurants, and quirky shops. Duval Street is the heart of the action, buzzing with nightlife, live music, and a welcoming energy that’s pure Key West.
For those craving sand and sea, Smathers Beach offers a classic stretch of shoreline perfect for relaxation or water sports. Whether you’re here for the island’s rich history, its world-class attractions, or just to soak up the sun, Key West is the ultimate destination for fun, relaxation, and adventure.
Types of Accommodations in Key West
No matter your travel style or budget, Key West has accommodations to match. From luxury resorts with ocean views to cozy motels just steps from Old Town, there’s a perfect spot for every visitor. Many Key West hotels and resorts are located within walking distance of top attractions like the Ernest Hemingway Home, making it easy to explore the island’s history and culture. Whether you’re looking for a boutique inn with a pool, a family-friendly resort, or a budget-friendly motel, you’ll find a wide range of options. West hotels often feature inviting pools, lush gardens, and easy access to the best of town, ensuring your stay is as comfortable as it is memorable.
Luxury Options
If you’re ready to indulge, Key West’s luxury hotels and resorts deliver the ultimate island experience. The Southernmost Beach Resort, located right on Duval Street, is a standout for its beachside resort vibe, stunning ocean views, and beautifully appointed guest rooms. Enjoy a continental breakfast by the pool, sip cocktails at the pool bar, and take advantage of free parking and free Wi-Fi throughout your stay. For a unique twist on luxury, Havana Cabana offers tropical decor, exceptional service, and a relaxing pool scene that feels worlds away from the everyday. Many of Key West’s top resorts combine prime locations, oceanfront pools, and thoughtful amenities—making it easy to unwind in style.
Budget-Friendly Options
Traveling on a budget? Key West has you covered with plenty of affordable hotels and motels that don’t skimp on comfort or convenience. Look for motels along Truman Ave or in New Town, where you’ll find some of the most affordable rates on the island. These budget-friendly options often include perks like free parking and are still within walking distance or a short drive to Old Town’s main attractions. Many of the best hotels for value-minded visitors offer clean, comfortable rooms and amazing service, so you can focus on exploring Key West without breaking the bank. Whether you’re staying just outside the action or right in the heart of town, you’ll find great deals and a warm welcome.
Lower Duval: For Sunset Cocktails + Prime Location
Lower Duval is where the island wakes up and winds down. It’s loud in all the right ways—buzzing bars, ocean views, and walkable everything. Many of the best Key West hotels are located along Duval St, making it a central hub for nightlife and top attractions. If it’s your first visit or you want to be in the center of the action, this is the place.
Ocean Key Resort & Spa
Vibe: Waterfront, polished, iconic
Why I love it: Front-row seats to Mallory Square sunsets, a spa worth your time, and cocktails at Sunset Pier that hit just right. The resort goes above and beyond to ensure guests enjoy exceptional amenities and personalized service throughout their stay.
Room tip: Spring for one with a water-facing balcony. Not all rooms have the view—and trust me, the upgrade is worth it if you plan to linger with a mojito and soak up the scene.
Pier House Resort & Spa
Vibe: Private beach energy with a side of spa day
Why I love it: Luxe without being flashy. The beach is small but secluded, and the property feels tucked away—even when Duval is buzzing.
La Concha Key West
Vibe: Classic, central, slightly chaotic (in a good way)
Why I love it: Recently refreshed, historic, and smack in the middle of Duval. Great rooftop views and next-level comfy beds.
Local lore: Yes, it’s allegedly haunted. No, I didn’t meet a ghost. But if you’re into spooky elevator stories and unexplained chills, ask a bartender.
Silver Palms Inn
Vibe: Welcoming, laid-back, and residential
Why I love it: It’s a short, pleasant walk to Duval with perks like free parking and a relaxed pool scene. Friendly staff, comfy rooms, and a quiet-but-close feel make it a smart option if you don’t need luxury but want location.
Upper Duval: For Boutique Vibes + Laid-Back Luxury
Upper Duval is more gallery than party. It’s artsy, romantic, and just a bit quieter—ideal for couples or anyone chasing that vintage Key West vibe without the late-night chaos. The neighborhood is home to some of Key West's most distinctive boutique hotels and romantic getaways, making it a perfect spot for those seeking a unique and intimate experience.
Orchid Key Inn
Vibe: Tropical-modern, adults-only
Why I love it: My go-to. Amazing staff, chic design, and a cocktail bar that hits all the right notes. Tucked away but still walkable to the action.
The Mansion on the Sea
Vibe: Historic drama with ocean views
Why I love it: Wraparound porches, grand staircases, and one of the most photogenic properties in Key West. Even if you don’t stay, stop by the Seaside Café.
Casa Marina Key West
Vibe: Grand, beachfront, a little weathered
Why I love it: The architecture is iconic, the beach is real (rare for Key West), and the setting is unmatched. It’s not perfect—but it’s still a classic.
New Town: For Space, Quiet, and Better Parking
New Town doesn’t make the glossy travel guides, but it should. It’s underrated, budget-friendlier, and gives you actual breathing room. Many New Town hotels also feature an outdoor pool, providing a relaxing spot for guests to unwind after exploring the island.
Bonus: most include shuttle service to Old Town.
Blue Flamingo Resort
Vibe: Clean, casual, easygoing
Why I love it: Solid pool, frequent shuttle service, and enough style to still feel like a vacation—not just a budget pick.
Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Vibe: Family-friendly resort that still feels elevated
Why I love it: Spacious suites, four pools, and quiet mornings on the porch. Great for groups or travelers who need a little room to spread out.
Hilton Garden Inn Key West
Vibe: Modern tropical, dependable
Why I love it: Good amenities, great value, and one of the highest-rated hotels in New Town. Shuttle service is reliable, and parking is a breeze.
DoubleTree Resort Grand Key
Vibe: Laid-back, practical
Why I love it: Comfy rooms, spacious pool, and a quieter stay—but you’ll need to plan around the hourly shuttle or grab an Uber.
Things to Do in Key West
Key West is packed with things to do, whether you’re here for adventure, relaxation, or a little bit of both. Spend your days lounging by the pool or on the sands of Smathers Beach, or dive into water activities like snorkeling, kayaking, and paddleboarding. Explore the historic Old Town, where you can visit the legendary Ernest Hemingway Home, tour the Keeper’s Quarters Museum, or snap a photo at the iconic Southernmost Point.
Duval Street is a must for nightlife, with its lively bars, restaurants, and live music venues that keep the island’s energy going long after sunset. Many hotels and resorts offer pools, spa services, and special packages for weddings or next events, making it easy to relax and celebrate in paradise. Whether you’re seeking fun, romance, or a taste of Key West’s rich history, this island has something for every guest.
FAQ: Where to Stay in Key West
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What’s the best area to stay in Key West? | It depends on your vibe. Lower Duval is for nightlife and views. Upper Duval brings boutique charm and a quieter pace. New Town offers space, savings, and shuttle service. |
| Are there beachfront hotels in Key West? | Casa Marina has a true private beach. Pier House has a small one, while Ocean Key is waterfront but lacks beach access. |
| Where should couples stay in Key West? | Upper Duval is your zone. Orchid Key Inn and Southernmost House are quiet, romantic, and walkable. |
| Best hotels for first-time visitors? | Lower Duval is the move. Ocean Key, Pier House, and La Concha all put you near the action and the sunset rituals. |
| Do hotels in Key West offer free wifi? | Yes, many hotels in Key West provide free wifi as a standard amenity, so you can stay connected throughout your visit. |
| Are there on-site dining options at Key West hotels? | Many hotels feature a restaurant on site or are located near top local eateries, making it easy to enjoy great food during your stay. |
| What on-site amenities do Key West hotels offer? | Most properties offer convenient on-site amenities and services, such as pools, fitness centers, and concierge assistance, to make your stay more comfortable. |
Final Take
If you're wondering where to stay in Key West, start with your vibe. Want sunset views and walkable chaos? Lower Duval is calling. Craving quiet luxury with a little edge? Upper Duval’s your match. Prefer space, a parking spot, and lower prices? Say hello to New Town.
Wherever you land, these are the hotels I’d personally book again—and in most cases, already have.
